Spoilers are labelled. Feelings are not.

Extraordinary Attorney Woo · Episode 8

Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 8 Recap

Plot summary (spoilers)Tap to reveal the main plot lines of this episode recap
  • An anonymous post accuses Young-woo of getting her Hanbada job through nepotism, and Su-yeon answers that no firm hiring her despite her grades was what was unfair.
  • At the rainy site visit, Taesan produces residents' consent forms, and the judge will dismiss the suit unless the route's opponents prove a majority by the next hearing.
  • Tae Su-mi offers Young-woo a place at Taesan, and when Young-woo tells her father she will take it, Gwang-ho reveals that Su-mi is her mother.
  • A provincial official admits that in 2016 he had coworkers pose as experts so the hackberry tree would not become a natural monument.
  • Hanbada challenges the judge over an umbrella from a construction company's model house, and Young-woo tells Su-mi who she is and turns down the offer.
  • The hackberry tree is designated a natural monument while the residents' lawsuit over the route is still running.

A nepotism post goes around Hanbada

Woo Young-woo wakes up at her friend Dong Geu-ra-mi's place after a bad night's sleep. Geu-ra-mi serves her own-brand gimbap (rice and fillings rolled in seaweed), with none of the ham, spinach or burdock Young-woo asks about, and Young-woo finds it strangely good. She did not fight with her father, she says. She left on her own and is moving out because she is an adult.

At the law firm Hanbada, staff whisper as Young-woo passes. A post on the firm's anonymous bulletin board accuses a rookie of getting her job through nepotism. She joined after the official recruitment period, skipped the rookie training and has a father who went to school with the firm's top attorney. The author says they feel robbed. Soon after, in an office, the post's author is confronted about writing it.

Woo Young-woo stands in the Hanbada open-plan office looking ahead while a colleague behind her turns.
Young-woo at Hanbada as the post circulates. Image: ASTORY, via the official teaser. Shown under fair use.

Hanbada's CEO, Han Seon-young, sits in on senior attorney Jung Myung-seok's team meeting, because the opposing counsel in their new case is Taesan's Tae Su-mi. The team represents the residents of Sodeok-dong, who are suing to revoke the road zone decision for Haengbok-ro, a road Gyeonghae-do province is building. Their only point of illegality is an environmental assessment done later than the law allows, which Seon-young calls a minor procedural slip. With construction still going on, she says, they are losing. The team hopes to move the judges at the coming on-site verification. Seon-young calls that romantic and asks for politics instead, such as a friendly outlet framing the case as David against Goliath, and orders them not to lose to Su-mi.

Choi Su-yeon shows Young-woo the post, which can only be about her. Young-woo says it is all true: her father and the CEO are university friends. Su-yeon disagrees. Top students at Seoul National University's law school are hired before they graduate, yet Young-woo, first in their class, was hired nowhere, and everyone, Su-yeon included, knew it was unfair and did nothing. She suspects their fellow rookie Kwon Min-woo wrote the post and tells Young-woo to smack him on the back of the head when they are alone. When Young-woo points out that would be a crime, Su-yeon tells her to stop letting people walk all over her and to be political, as the CEO said.

Choi Su-yeon in a beige blazer talks animatedly in a bright office.
Choi Su-yeon at Hanbada. Image: ASTORY, via the official teaser. Shown under fair use.

A site visit in the rain

On the day of the on-site verification, it pours in Sodeok-dong. Hanbada has invited the newspaper Jungui Ilbo, whose team arrives soaked. When the judge arrives, the head of the town leads the group along red flags marking Haengbok-ro's route through the homes.

The residents go by nicknames, and Kim Jeong-hwan is Heung-min, after the soccer star Son Heung-min. As he is introduced, Taesan, the rival firm representing Gyeonghae-do, reveals that he has signed a consent form accepting a new compensation amount for his land, though he sits on the board of the Residents' Countermeasures Committee. Jeong-hwan says the attorneys told him it could double, and the land will be taken anyway. His neighbor Jang-hoon has signed too. Hanbada calls the forms a trick to divide the residents, since the increase is not even confirmed. Taesan replies that the town head holds too much power over his neighbors, and that 343 of the 488 households facing expropriation signed within fifteen days.

On the hilltop, the judge turns down a cup of sikhye, a sweet rice drink, in the cold rain, then doubts aloud that the committee speaks for all of Sodeok-dong. When the residents protest that the attorneys split them with tricks, the judge sets a test. Both sides must collect consent forms by the next hearing, and if the route's opponents are not a majority, the claim will be dismissed. The reporter leaves with nothing to write.

Tae Su-mi's offer under the hackberry tree

Over a map of the town, the committee marks likely supporters in blue and households expected to take compensation in red. Taesan already has part-timers going door to door, while the ones Lee Jun-ho has found for Hanbada are still on their way. A resident rounds up the women's association, whose members want a song before they sign. While her colleagues sing about a promise to meet at Andong Station on the day of the first snow, Young-woo slips off to find the bag she left under the hackberry tree.

Su-mi is there with it. She knows Young-woo's name from the statement of opinion in Chairman Kim Jeong-gu's wedding-dress case, which Kim showed her. She asks whether Young-woo would come to Taesan, and calls Hanbada's site-visit plan naive: "There's nothing weaker than a person's mind," especially when money is involved. As they are on opposite sides of this case, she leaves it there, asking Young-woo to visit Taesan once it ends so they can win trials together. The two of them look up at the tree and agree it is amazing.

Afterwards, Min-woo asks what she and Attorney Tae talked about. Young-woo asks whether he means to put it on the anonymous board again, and warns that she will smack him if he does it once more. Min-woo calls her shameless. Who wrote the post does not matter, he says, because it is all true.

Young-woo tells her father she is leaving

At home, Young-woo stops by for clothes. She tells her father, Woo Gwang-ho, that she is moving in with Geu-ra-mi and leaving Hanbada for Taesan on an offer from Su-mi. Gwang-ho says she cannot go there. "Tae Su-mi is your mom!" he shouts, and he tells her Su-mi is the woman who gave birth to her. She leaves as her father calls her name.

She wakes up in a hospital bed, bruised all over but with no broken bones. Gwang-ho apologizes for the lie that her mother died giving birth to her. Young-woo already knew. Her grandmother, very drunk, once yelled at her that her mother was not dead but had abandoned her and run away.

Gwang-ho tells the rest. He was a poor farmer's son and Su-mi the daughter of Taesan's founder, and they fell for each other at university. When she became pregnant, Su-mi changed. In a flashback, young Gwang-ho goes to her house and begs her to have the baby, promising to take the child and disappear, quit his studies and never sit the bar exam. Su-mi agreed and stayed home until the birth while claiming to study in the United States. The baby girl was handed to Gwang-ho with orders never to contact Su-mi again, and he gave up the bar so he would never run into her.

He regrets it now, having watched Young-woo fail to find work. He thought keeping his promise made him loyal and cool, and she tells him he is. But he says he should have become an attorney anyway, with a practice where he could hire and teach her. Everything in life is political, he says. Seon-young had a political reason to hire Young-woo, and Su-mi left not out of hatred but because political reasons kept her from marrying a man like him.

The tree that never got its review

His words make Young-woo think of the hackberry tree. In 2016 the residents asked about protecting it, and experts judged it unworthy of becoming a natural monument, a protected status. She sends her father out, citing attorney-client privilege, and calls Myung-seok. By 2016, she argues, the road plan was already quietly known, so the tree may have been passed over for a political reason. It is 3:10 a.m., and Myung-seok tells her it can wait until daylight.

In Kiyoung, where Sodeok-dong lies, the procedure is laid out: Gyeonghae-do's Cultural Heritage Committee reviews a tree first and then reports to the Cultural Heritage Administration. The residents left the 2016 request to Park Yu-jin, who plays the violin and works at the provincial office. There, Young-woo and Jun-ho tell Park that the Administration never received a report on the tree. He goes to look for the committee's records.

While they wait, Jun-ho asks whether she got home safely the day she ran out of Myung-seok's office. Young-woo says her heart raced that day, even though she did not touch him. "I think I do like you," she says. Jun-ho starts to answer, but Young-woo has spotted Park running away.

They chase him down, and Park says he ran out of embarrassment. In 2016 a friend warned him that subway line ten and Haengbok-ro were coming to Sodeok-dong, and that a natural monument would block both. So he had coworkers pose as committee experts, inspect the tree in front of the town head and declare it not good enough. The committee was never asked. Park's umbrella is printed with an Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin, the logo of Kyungpo Construction, and he got it at a model house.

Young-woo turns down Taesan

At the next hearing, 1,557 of Sodeok-dong's 2,513 households have consented to Gyeonghae-do's decision, more than half, and the judge prepares to dismiss the claim. Hanbada files a motion to challenge the court, asking for the judge to be replaced over possible bias. The grounds are the judge's umbrella at the site visit, which bears Kyungpo Construction's dolphin logo and was handed out at the model house for Kyungpo Ocean Park Apartments in the planned city of Hamun. The judge does not know where the umbrella came from, but Hanbada argues that any interest in buying there raises the risk of an unfair trial.

At Taesan, Su-mi tells her head of HR that Young-woo looks naive but has already one-upped her several times. Young-woo arrives, asks to speak with Su-mi alone, and asks whether Su-mi recognizes her: she is Woo Gwang-ho's daughter. She wanted to leave Hanbada to be independent of her father, she explains, but she cannot leave him for the firm of a mother who abandoned her and does not recognize her even now. She thanks Su-mi for the offer and says she will stay at Hanbada, by her father's side.

Woo Young-woo and Tae Su-mi sit facing each other on sofas in a bright office with a city view.
Young-woo and Su-mi meet. Image: ASTORY, via the official teaser. Shown under fair use.

Talk then turns to the hackberry tree, which looks set to be named a natural monument, so Gyeonghae-do will have to move Haengbok-ro whether or not the judge is replaced. One of them asks whether she is resented for what she has done. Young-woo closes the meeting by saying it was nice to look at the tree together on the hill, and nice to meet Su-mi at least once, as she had wanted.

On the news, the Cultural Heritage Administration designates the hackberry tree in Sodeok-dong a natural monument, citing its historic, scenic and aesthetic value. The report notes that the residents are still suing Gyeonghae-do over a route that would cut through the town and the tree.