Extraordinary Attorney Woo · Episode 3
Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 3 Recap
Plot summary (spoilers)Tap to reveal the main plot lines of this episode recap
- Hanbada defends Kim Jeong-hun, a young man with severe autism charged after his older brother Sang-hun dies with 22 broken ribs.
- On her father's advice, Young-woo reaches Jeong-hun through his love of Pengsoo, which points her to his brother's suicide attempts.
- The chairman fires Hanbada after reading Sang-hun's diary, and his wife asks the team back on the condition that the attempts stay hidden.
- In court, the prosecutor turns Young-woo's own autism against the defense, and the chairman later asks that she leave the trial.
- Young-woo works out how Sang-hun's ribs could have broken while Jeong-hun was trying to save his brother, and Myung-seok steps off the case with her.
- Jang Seung-jun finishes the trial, and Young-woo prepares a letter of resignation from Hanbada.
A brother's death and a client who will not talk
In a dark family home, a couple comes back to find their elder son, Kim Sang-hun, unresponsive. Their younger son, Kim Jeong-hun, screams "Die! Stop!" At the law firm Hanbada, Woo Young-woo now has her own nameplate, and Jung Myung-seok calls her in with a new case. The client is the chairman of Sangjeong Pharmaceutical, a long-time Hanbada client. Jeong-hun is charged with bodily injury resulting in death: Sang-hun died of chest bleeding from 22 rib fractures, was drunk at the time and had a faint mark on his neck. Myung-seok wants Young-woo on the case because Jeong-hun has autism, and she asks him outright whether that is the reason. She starts to explain the autism spectrum through whale species until he cuts her off. They agree that neither has met anyone like Jeong-hun, whose evaluation puts his mental age between six and ten.
The chairman and his wife, Jeon Gyeong-hee, tell the lawyers the brothers were close. Sang-hun, a Seoul National University medical student with a perfect score on the national college entrance exam, looked after Jeong-hun. Jeong-hun, they say, has never threatened or attacked anyone. Asked about the incident, he repeats only the same words about dying and stopping, and one parent admits to knowing little about what goes on in their sons' minds. At lunch in the basement cafeteria, Young-woo tells Lee Jun-ho how whales feed off Ulsan and sleep off the west coast of Japan. A colleague who wants to stop her is told that Jun-ho does not seem to mind.
Jeong-hun then comes to Hanbada. He wears headphones and sunglasses and refuses to take them off. He calls out the name of Pengsoo, the giant penguin character from the Korean broadcaster EBS. When Young-woo asks why he hit his brother, he echoes her question back at her. He keeps repeating it until he is too agitated to go on.
Gwang-ho's advice and the Pengsoo song
At home, Young-woo asks her father, Woo Gwang-ho, how to talk with an autistic man of 21. She gives no details because of attorney-client privilege. Gwang-ho admits that raising her felt lonely. He remembers his own mother pushing blind dates and marriage on him, and telling her that with her bad back she could not raise the girl. He also remembers crying out in pain after stepping on a young Young-woo's LEGO. Things changed when she took to the law, the one thing they could share, and he recalls calming her crying fit at the Obuk Corner Store by reciting minor-offense law. His advice is to dig into whatever her client loves. When she calls that too obvious, he answers that methods always are; the hard part is carrying them out, and it takes time.
Back at Hanbada, over doubts from her colleagues, the lawyers greet Jeong-hun with Pengsoo's greeting, Peng-ha, and sing Pengsoo's song for him. He demands an encore, and Young-woo will only agree if he answers first. Pressed again, he breaks down shouting the same words about dying and stopping. Young-woo suddenly asks whether his brother tried to die. She tells the room the word may describe what Sang-hun did, not what anyone said, and points to his 0.321 percent blood alcohol level and the faint neck mark in the autopsy. A parent insists Sang-hun never attempted suicide. When Jeong-hun answers yes both to whether his brother tried to die and whether he tried to live, the family ends the lawyers' meetings with him.
The diary in Sang-hun's room
Young-woo and Jun-ho go to the family's apartment to search Sang-hun's belongings. Their reasoning is that the police saw no need to look hard in a case that seemed simple. In the building, a college friend of Jun-ho's asks whether he is still volunteering for Nanuri, and Young-woo asks if that is a volunteer group for disabled people. Jun-ho apologizes for his friend, and Young-woo says she can see how it looks. In Sang-hun's room, she works out that Jeong-hun, nearly two meters tall, could have reached up and untied a knot, letting his brother drop. She then spots a piece of rope that looks roughly torn off, and they also find Sang-hun's diary from the previous year.
The lawyers tell the parents the rope has gone to the National Forensic Service for comparison with the neck mark, then show them the diary pages. In them, Sang-hun calls himself a loser who expects to keep failing exams. He writes that he tries to hang himself out of habit and does not care if his brother sees. Jeong-hun now watches over him every night, he adds, and that comforts him. The parents ask if the lawyers are punishing them and fear the truth would disgrace a son famous for his grades. Young-woo argues that the living son's sentence outweighs the dead son's honor, and that the defense can show the cause of Jeong-hun's outburst is gone. The father tells her to be quiet, throws "You're autistic yourself!" at her, and ends Sangjeong's relationship with Hanbada.
Jeong-hun comes back to Hanbada
Afterward, Jun-ho tries to find the words for an apology to Young-woo over his friend's remark. A news report describes the case. Online, a comment calling the medical student's death a national loss draws 299 likes.
Later, Jeong-hun turns up at Hanbada in a taxi he does not pay for, and someone there covers the fare. His mother comes to collect him and asks the team to take the case back. Her condition is that they leave Sang-hun's attempts out, since Jeong-hun's autism may win him a lighter sentence anyway; she will win over her husband. She also apologizes, admitting the couple could not help comparing Young-woo with Jeong-hun. Young-woo says that Hans Asperger, the first autism researcher, saw promise in autistic people but also worked with the Nazis to sort out children deemed unworthy of life. Eighty years ago, she says, she and Jeong-hun would have been among them, and hundreds still like that comment today.
The prosecutor turns on Young-woo
In court, with Hanbada back on the defense, Young-woo questions a psychiatrist, who describes a meltdown as an involuntary explosion of suppressed stress in autistic people, sometimes violent. On cross-examination, the prosecutor asks how many autistic patients are in the courtroom and names Young-woo as one. The defense objects, but the judge overrules, finding the question neither irrelevant nor discriminatory. The psychiatrist confirms Young-woo has autism while objecting to calling autistic people patients. After a second objection, the defense argues that a disability alone does not make someone mentally unfit. The prosecutor then asks why an autistic defendant should get a lighter sentence while an autistic attorney's arguments count the same as anyone else's, and calls it an irony in the defense's case.
Later, Jun-ho gets Young-woo out of a knot tied around her neck. He holds her up with his left hand under her backside and unties the knot with his right. She topples backward onto the floor. The fall shows her how Sang-hun's ribs could have broken.
Young-woo takes what she has learned to the chairman. Sang-hun had five fractures on the front right ribs and six on the front left, likely from CPR. The other 11 run in a straight line down the back of his right ribs. If Jeong-hun held Sang-hun up while untying the knot, she explains, Sang-hun could have fallen onto his back and broken those ribs. Jeong-hun would then be cleared of causing his brother's death and face only an assault charge and a much lighter sentence, though Sang-hun's attempts would have to come out. The father, who calls children a parent's report card, agrees for Jeong-hun's sake. He then asks that the trial go on without Young-woo, citing the prosecutor's attack.
Myung-seok objects, but Young-woo sides with the chairman. People mistake Jun-ho for her volunteer helper, she says. The taxi driver never saw her as able to settle the fare either. So the judges, she concludes, will not see the difference between her autism and Jeong-hun's.
Myung-seok steps aside, and Seung-jun takes over
Myung-seok asks the CEO, Han Seon-young, to talk the chairman round, calling his request discrimination. She reminds him of his earlier complaints about Young-woo's résumé, and he answers that she was not on his team then and is now. Seon-young agrees the request is unfair but says she must serve the client. Myung-seok should stay out of court as well, she says, and show the client that he and Young-woo are one team. As a penalty, she hands the case to Jang Seung-jun. Seung-jun, hanging upside down, pretends not to hear until Myung-seok asks him three times for the favor, then agrees to handle the case.
At the next hearing, Seung-jun questions a medical examiner from the National Forensic Service. The front fractures came from CPR after death, the examiner says. The diagonal line along the back points to one large impact, a fall after hanging, and the rope matches the neck marks. An agitated attacker would have trouble striking such a neat line. The judge then asks Jeong-hun whether he dropped his brother and whether he was trying to save him. He answers yes to every question, which leads the judge to call him mentally unfit at present.
The prosecution has demanded seven years plus treatment and custody. Even so, the defense expects an acquittal on the death charge and probation for the assault. A parent apologizes to Young-woo, who says it is fine. Later, Young-woo prepares a letter of resignation from Hanbada, citing personal reasons.
Up next: Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 4 recap. See every episode in the Extraordinary Attorney Woo episode guide.
