Extraordinary Attorney Woo · Episode 6
Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 6 Recap
Plot summary (spoilers)Tap to reveal the main plot lines of this episode recap
- Gye Hyang-sim leaves her daughter Ha-yun at an orphanage and turns herself in, five years after fleeing her trial for injury resulting from robbery.
- Myung-seok sends Young-woo to calm Su-yeon down, but both rookies set out to win Hyang-sim probation.
- Police records show the victim's husband beat her two days before the incident, and Young-woo exposes the doctor's bias against defectors in court.
- The doctor turns out to be an executive of a doctors' group worth billions to Hanbada, and Myung-seok takes the blame for losing the client.
- Young-woo argues North Korean law in court, then she and Su-yeon plead in the judge's chambers and are turned away.
- The jury recommends four years, but the judge suspends a sentence of one year and nine months mainly because Hyang-sim confessed.
A mother leaves Ha-yun and turns herself in
At the Gureum Orphanage, Gye Hyang-sim holds her sleeping daughter, Ha-yun, as she registers her with the staff. She admits she gave the girl medicine so she would not fight the separation. Asked for an address, Hyang-sim insists Ha-yun is not up for adoption. She is leaving her only because she may be going to prison. She asks the staff not to look down on Ha-yun as a North Korean defector's daughter. Ha-yun wakes and screams for her mother, and Hyang-sim promises to be back soon.

At the law firm Hanbada, senior attorney Jung Myung-seok hands Woo Young-woo a public interest case: a North Korean defector on a charge of injury resulting from robbery. He sees little hope and thinks Attorney Choi, who already has it, is too emotionally involved. He tells Young-woo to join her and calm her down, and they practice a soothing "whoa, whoa" hand gesture. Young-woo passes the instruction straight on to Choi Su-yeon, who takes her to meet the defendant at the detention center.
There, Hyang-sim mishears Young-woo's name and calls her Comrade Woo Hyang-woo. Five years ago, a defector broker everyone calls Mom, Choi Yeong-hui, owed Hyang-sim 10 million won. Instead of paying, Mom told her to collect the money from a woman named Lee Sun-yeong. Hyang-sim and another defector, Kim Jeong-hui, stormed into Sun-yeong's home to demand it. The landlord downstairs called the police about the noise, and both were arrested on the spot. Jeong-hui stood trial before a jury and got four years, but Hyang-sim fled before hers.

Ha-yun was three then, and her father was dead. As defectors, mother and daughter had no one, and a child left at an orphanage that young would have forgotten her mother. Now Ha-yun is eight, old enough to remember, and needs to start school, so Hyang-sim has turned herself in. Young-woo compares her to a mother whale, devoted because the ocean has few safe places for a calf. When Hyang-sim asks them to bring Ha-yun to visit her in prison once, Su-yeon says there will be no four-year sentence: Hyang-sim will get probation.
A biased diagnosis and a noisy address
Back at Hanbada, Young-woo tells Myung-seok they will fight for probation. The charge carries life or at least seven years, mitigation can cut that only to three and a half, and probation needs a sentence under three. The accomplice's trial has already produced the answer of four years. Su-yeon wants to argue there was no real bodily harm, but Myung-seok points to the victim's photos. Young-woo notes the injuries look too severe for two women with bare hands in a few minutes, and he lets them dig.

That night, a drunk Lee Jun-ho tells Kwon Min-woo about someone he sees often who thinks he dislikes them, when he actually likes them. Min-woo wonders aloud if it is Woo Young-woo, and Jun-ho tells him to forget it. Min-woo claims he can see what is going on and settles on Choi.
At the courthouse, Su-yeon and Young-woo find Kwon Ju-ho, the public defender who represented both women. A doctor's diagnosis is the hardest evidence to overturn, he says, even when it rests on what the patient reports. Then he recalls a newspaper piece the doctor later wrote about defectors, which clearly refers to this case.

At Sun-yeong's building on Dongbaek-gil, a man storms out with money as Sun-yeong begs him not to take it, and Young-woo is caught in the scuffle. The landlord downstairs is already phoning the police, and says the husband beats his wife constantly and the calls have gone on for five years. Officers now come as fast as a jjajangmyeon delivery (black-bean noodles, Korea's classic takeout). Young-woo and Su-yeon realize there must be police records from before the incident.
At Hanbada, Min-woo tells Su-yeon he thinks Jun-ho likes her, since she fits the clues. She asks whether Jun-ho said something about her, then insists she is not curious.
A judge who asks about family origins
At a hearing on summoning Sun-yeong as a witness, the prosecutor objects that she was cross-examined five years ago. Young-woo cuts in to argue that even a defendant who fled has a right to a fair trial. Judge Ryu Myeong-ha asks her family origin, the ancestral clan seat attached to a Korean surname. Then he tells her interrupting is banned in his courtroom. The prosecutor flatters him about his own origin. When the judge then cuts off Su-yeon to ask her family origin, Young-woo points it out. The judge rules that for the rest of the trial, attorneys must raise their hands before speaking.
Su-yeon raises hers. She is a Choi of Wonju, and Chief Judge Choi Bo-yeon, her father, has his office on the judge's floor. The judge calls him a dear junior colleague and grants the summons. Later, watching Jun-ho and Su-yeon together, Min-woo says they make a good-looking match.
At the jury trial, Myung-seok sends Su-yeon to question Sun-yeong gently. Over objections, Su-yeon asks whether Sun-yeong's husband caused her bruises. She produces police records of a call on November 6, 2017, two days before the incident, when the husband assaulted her. Sun-yeong says she does not recall. Hyang-sim jumps up and shouts that Sun-yeong is pinning her husband's beatings on her. Myung-seok starts to answer without raising his hand, and Young-woo has to remind him. The judge sends the witness home, bars her from facing the defendant in court again and calls a recess.
Outside, Myung-seok tells Hyang-sim a trial is not a marketplace fight. She shoots back that when an attorney does it, it is called strategy. The rookies calm her: the trial is about her sentence, and Ha-yun is waiting. With the doctor up next, Myung-seok plans to attack his bias against defectors and gives the cross-examination to Young-woo.
Young-woo puts the doctor on the spot
The doctor reads out his diagnosis and blames the defendant and her accomplice. Under cross-examination he admits he never knew about the husband's assault, yet still blames Hyang-sim. He can tell from the injuries because he is a doctor, he says, and offers no medical basis. Young-woo produces his newspaper piece from early 2018. He asks not to discuss it, citing the hate mail it brought, but the judge finds no legal ground to refuse. He reads the title: "North Korean defectors are becoming a criminal group."
Young-woo suggests he blames the defendant over the husband because she is a defector, and the prosecution's objection is sustained. The doctor then protests that a normal South Korean man is being made an abuser to help defectors, and that taxpayers' trials should protect citizens. She tells the doctor that defectors are South Korean citizens too, which is why the trial is being held.
At a restaurant, a Hanbada colleague berates Myung-seok in front of the rookies. The doctor, Kwon Byeong-gil, is an executive of the Group of Righteous Doctors, a client worth billions that the colleague worked hard to land. Now it is lost over a mere public interest case, and the colleague complains that the one peer who should help is doing harm. When the rookies apologize for not checking the witness, Myung-seok says the mistake is his alone. He asks them never to call this a mere public interest case or Hyang-sim a mere defector. Then he leaves, embarrassed.
Ha-yun comes to see her mother, and Hyang-sim tells her again and again that she is sorry. A flashback follows to a school family sports day, where little Young-woo asks her father, Woo Gwang-ho, why she does not have a mom.
North Korean law and a visit to the judge's chambers
At Hanbada, Su-yeon proposes challenging the law itself, since the minimum for murder is only five years. Young-woo notes it was upheld as constitutional in 2001, 2006 and 2016. No law treats refugees or foreigners more leniently, she adds. Pressed for an idea, she offers a far-fetched one: North Korean law.
In court, Young-woo cites Article 288 of North Korea's criminal law. Robbery of personal property carries a correctional labor camp term of up to four years, but only with violence, or threats of it, severe enough to kill or seriously injure. Anything less is theft under Article 284, punishable by up to a year of labor discipline. Hyang-sim, she argues, only wanted her money back and did not think it was robbery. The judge, calling the logic unprecedented, questions Hyang-sim himself. She says she went to get the money at all costs, because it was hers, and admits she does not really know North Korean law.
As the jury deliberates, Myung-seok heads back to the office, and Hyang-sim asks whether prison is already decided. Young-woo decides to try a constitutional claim and runs off, with Su-yeon chasing her. To get past the access desk to the judges' chambers, Su-yeon says she is Chief Judge Choi Bo-yeon's daughter on a personal errand. Inside, she groans that she let Wild Card Woo Young-woo talk her into this.
The two burst into Judge Ryu's chambers to ask him to reopen the hearing. Since Hyang-sim never got the money, they argue, trying her for the completed crime is unconstitutional. The judge answers that an attempt under this charge concerns the injury, not the robbery. Young-woo pleads that Hyang-sim, like a mother whale, lived as a fugitive for five years so her daughter would remember her. The judge refuses to weigh arguments made outside court and threatens to call a bailiff.
Outside, Young-woo tells Su-yeon how whalers harpoon the calf first, knowing the mother will stay beside it, and then harpoon her. The mother knows she will die if she stays, and she stays anyway. Then Young-woo asks, "If I were a whale, would my mom not have abandoned me?"
The verdict
The seven jurors unanimously find Hyang-sim guilty and recommend four years in prison. The judge sentences her to one year and nine months, suspended for three years, with probation and 80 hours of community service. He explains that he weighed her unfamiliarity with South Korean law and her clean record. Above all, he weighed her confession, made after five years to accept punishment. Young-woo and Su-yeon realize they forgot the most basic ground for mitigation, and credit the cleverness of a veteran judge.
At a department store, a clerk and a shopper talk about daughters, and the answer is just a son. Su-yeon has dragged Young-woo to a sale and urges her to buy a new bag, though Young-woo dislikes department stores. Not long after, Young-woo wants to go home while Su-yeon still has more to see, and Su-yeon asks her why.
Up next: Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 7 recap. Previous: Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 5 recap. See every episode in the Extraordinary Attorney Woo episode guide.
