Extraordinary Attorney Woo · Episode 1
Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 1 Recap
Plot summary (spoilers)Tap to reveal the main plot lines of this episode recap
- Woo Young-woo, a rookie attorney with autism spectrum disorder, joins Hanbada, where senior attorney Jung Myung-seok gives her a case as a test.
- Her client is Choi Yeong-ran, her childhood neighbor, charged with attempted murder after hitting her husband with an iron.
- Young-woo finds that an attempted-murder verdict would cost Yeong-ran her husband's pension and the house after his death.
- The husband dies mid-trial and the charge becomes murder, until Young-woo shows that an illness may have caused his brain bleed.
- Yeong-ran is found not guilty of murder and gets probation for inflicting bodily injury.
- Lee Jun-ho helps Young-woo through the office's revolving door and tells her she can talk about whales with him.
A five-year-old recites the criminal code
On November 17, 2000, a doctor tells Woo Gwang-ho that his five-year-old daughter, Woo Young-woo, who has never said a word, appears to be autistic. At Yeongran Villa, the building where they rent a flat, the landlord accuses Gwang-ho of carrying on with his wife, who has been babysitting Young-woo. He orders Gwang-ho out and starts hitting him. In the middle of the fight, Young-woo recites the criminal law on inflicting bodily injury, penalties included. Gwang-ho realizes that his daughter can talk, and that she has memorized a thick criminal-law casebook.
The landlord's wife, Choi Yeong-ran, brings ointment and apologizes for her husband. When a tearful Gwang-ho tells her what Young-woo can do, Yeong-ran calls the girl a genius who could grow up to be an attorney. In voice-over, the adult Young-woo calls it the day her father learned his daughter was an autistic genius.
Twenty-two years later, Young-woo introduces herself the way she always does. Her name reads the same forwards and backwards, like kayak, deed, rotator, noon and racecar. At breakfast, Gwang-ho serves her the Woo Young-woo gimbap, rice and fillings rolled in seaweed. She eats it every morning because she can see every ingredient, so no texture or flavor takes her by surprise. She recites her route to the new office: Hapjeong Station, line 2 to Yeoksam, exit 4, 38 minutes in all. Before she leaves, Gwang-ho sets the rules for her first day: no repeating other people's words, nothing odd or too blunt, and above all no whale talk. She asks what happens if a situation truly calls for whales, and he allows it only then.
Young-woo's first day at Hanbada
At the law firm Hanbada's building near Yeoksam Station, Young-woo stops dead at the revolving door until a young employee talks her through it step by step. He walks her to the office of senior attorney Jung Myung-seok, and colleagues greet him on the way as Jun-ho. Myung-seok is not expecting her, and his copy of her résumé is missing its second page, which she tells him lists autism spectrum disorder. Asked if she has anything else to say, Young-woo repeats her palindrome introduction, and he leaves the room. A rookie who went to law school with her points to a note on the résumé asking him to take care of her. It is signed Han, which the rookie reads as the firm's CEO.
In the CEO's office, Myung-seok raises the second page with Hanbada's CEO, Han Seon-young, who has read both. The CEO points out that Young-woo graduated top of her class from Seoul National University's law school, with a bar exam score above 1,500. Myung-seok replies that a good memory is not enough: he needs a lawyer who can meet clients and speak well in court. He offers to test the rookie with a case, to see whether she is unqualified or he is prejudiced against people with disabilities. The CEO agrees that he can let her go if she falls short.
The case is a public-interest assignment. The defendant, a woman in her seventies who cares for a husband with mild dementia, struck him on the forehead with an iron during a fight. Young-woo says the iron looks like a sperm whale and launches into whale facts and Moby-Dick until Myung-seok tells her to focus.
A flashback shows the day of the incident. The husband complains that his head feels ready to split. Then he flies into a jealous rage when his wife chats with a young delivery man, and calls her a vile name. She tells him they should both die that day and swings the iron, and he collapses as she calls for help. He suffers a brain hemorrhage, and she is charged with attempted murder. Since the prosecution has not even sought an arrest warrant, Myung-seok sets a simple goal: probation.
In the conference room, the defendant turns out to be Choi Yeong-ran. Young-woo tells her she recognized the address, because she and her father lived in House 201 of Yeongran Villa twenty-two years ago. Yeong-ran is overjoyed that the little girl became an attorney and asks after Gwang-ho. Young-woo's questions draw out the facts. The husband was diagnosed with dementia about five years ago and retired as a section chief at the district office. The couple live on his pension and the rent, and the villa is in his name even though it is named after her.
Back in his office, Myung-seok reads Young-woo's statement of opinion and balks: she plans to plead not guilty to attempted murder. The prosecution already leans toward probation, he says, so remorse and the victim's forgiveness should be enough. She answers with a whale quiz about a sperm whale's weight, whose answer is "Whales cannot lay eggs." The point, she explains, lies in civil law, not criminal law. Under the Civil Act's Article 1004, anyone who tries to kill a spouse cannot inherit from them. An attempted-murder verdict would cost Yeong-ran the pension and the house after her husband's death, so Young-woo will aim for probation for inflicting bodily injury instead.
Myung-seok praises her and admits he took the case too lightly. He arranges for an employee to go with her to the hospital, noting that meetings outside the office are hard even for ordinary attorneys. When he apologizes for the remark, she tells him it is fine, "Because I'm not an ordinary attorney."
A hospital visit and a jury trial
At the office, Jun-ho, who works on the litigation team, is sent to accompany a rookie attorney to the hospital. In the lobby he finds Young-woo in front of the revolving door, listing its one advantage and three disadvantages. He suggests she treat it like a waltz and count one, two, three. A phone call reveals that each has been waiting for the other, and he introduces himself as Lee Jun-ho. When he remarks that her name reads the same backward, she reminds him that kind of talk is not for work, and he suggests they take it outside. They go through the door together on the count.
At the hospital, a doctor shows them a scan of the husband's subdural hematoma, a pool of blood under the brain's outer membrane, but no fracture. Asked whether the bleed could have another cause, the doctor calls it unlikely. In the ward, the husband wakes, and once Yeong-ran reminds him of the girl from House 201, he repeats his old accusation about Gwang-ho and Yeong-ran. He curses Young-woo with the same words he shouted in 2000 and orders her out. Afterwards, Yeong-ran admits she told the police she wanted to kill him, and says that is how she feels now. Young-woo explains that the charge depends on her intent at the moment of the blow, from attempted murder down to negligence. When Yeong-ran says she may have wanted to kill him, Young-woo notes that she drew the curtains so the light would not wake him, something people do for those they love.
At Hanbada, Jun-ho says that after watching the husband curse, he could understand why the old woman hit him. Myung-seok decides to request a jury trial. On the evidence alone, a blow with an iron looks like attempted murder, but jurors can be moved by Yeong-ran's situation. Another rookie attorney offers to help, citing a news anchor exam and a speech contest win, and Myung-seok replies that anchor-style delivery could backfire. Young-woo argues that if the defense rests on pity, nothing draws more of it than a disability, and she has autism spectrum disorder. Myung-seok tells her to handle the trial alone and to practice speaking so she is not humiliated in court as a Hanbada attorney.
Afterwards, the other rookie wonders aloud whether Young-woo is only pretending. Her law-school classmate explains her nickname, FWA, short for "First place is Woo Young-woo Anyway," and admits to always helping Young-woo only to finish behind her. Young-woo gets stuck at the revolving door again and is told to use the other door. In voice-over, she gives her name's meanings as flower and luck, then wonders whether clever and foolish would fit better. She remembers every book she has read, yet she cannot pass through a revolving door.
That night at a pub, Young-woo's friend Dong Geu-ra-mi, who works there, is pestering her boss for 100,000 won and insisting on cleaning after being told to stop. The two friends trade their usual name chant, and Geu-ra-mi serves Young-woo her regular gimbap. Young-woo asks for help preparing to speak before a jury. Geu-ra-mi acts out courtroom scenes from the Korean films Innocent Witness and The Attorney, then drills Young-woo on shouting an objection with full force.
Mr. Park takes the stand
At Seoul Central District Court, Young-woo does not answer the roll call until she is prompted. Prosecutor Choi Hyeon-uk lays out the attempted-murder charge. When the judge calls for the defense's opening statement, Young-woo sits silent. Then she stands and asks the jury for understanding. She has autism spectrum disorder, she says, and her speech and manner may seem awkward, but she loves the law and respects her client as much as any attorney would. The prosecutor answers with a mocking remark about her love of the law.
The prosecutor confronts Yeong-ran with her police statement that she wanted to kill her husband, and she says she only said it because she was nervous. He reads out her words about both of them dying that day. Young-woo objects to a leading question, and the judge sustains it. The prosecutor shows the court the iron and has Yeong-ran confirm she hit her husband on the head. When he presses her on whether she wanted him dead, an objection is overruled, and Yeong-ran breaks down, apologizing and begging the court for mercy.
After the hearing, the defense accuses the prosecutor of questioning an old woman like a gang member. He answers that he meant to go easy, but now that Hanbada is contesting guilt, he will go all in. The defense team decides to call the husband, Park Gyu-sik, so he can tell the jury in person that he does not want his wife punished. The existing letter is only a form Park signed. Because of Park's temper and his grudge against Young-woo, the plan is for Myung-seok to question him, with Young-woo drafting the questions.
In court, once Park is sworn in, Myung-seok changes the plan and sends Young-woo instead. Repeating Jun-ho's remark, he tells her to go get cursed at. When she introduces herself as Yeong-ran's attorney, Park explodes, accuses them all of plotting against him and repeats the curse from 2000. A scuffle breaks out, and the judge calls a ten-minute recess.
Later, the defense tells the jury that Park, as they saw, is suspicious and abusive, and that Yeong-ran cared for him through his dementia. She may have struck him in a moment of anger, the defense says, but she is not a wife who tried to murder her husband. The prosecutor interrupts with news that Park has died while being taken to the hospital. As Yeong-ran asks in shock who has died, the prosecution moves to change the charge to murder.
A headache before the iron
Young-woo wonders whether Park would still be alive if she had not questioned him, or had never taken the case. She tells Yeong-ran that her first words in front of people were the law on inflicting bodily injury. Yeong-ran, she adds, was the first person to say she would become an attorney. She wanted so badly to do well on her first case that she was greedy, she says, and she apologizes for Park's death. Yeong-ran refuses to let her take the blame. It was her husband's fault, she says, for cursing the neighbor's child he had not seen in twenty years. It was her own for swinging the iron without knowing he was so near the end. He always complained that his head hurt, she adds, and she weeps for him.
At Hanbada, Jun-ho brings Young-woo the autopsy report: Park died of a brain hemorrhage, a recurrence of the subdural hematoma he had surgery for. He remarks on how frightening the iron looks, and they agree it resembles the sperm whale. Young-woo runs through the things she cannot do at work, whale talk included. Jun-ho tells her that when it is just the two of them, she can talk about whales.
Thinking of her whale quiz, Young-woo wonders whether Park's doctor fixed on the iron the way a solver fixes on the whale's weight. She finds a line in Park's police statement, page 24, line 7: a package arrived while he was lying on the couch with a headache. He was in pain before the iron ever touched him, and the bleed may not have come from the blow.
Back in court, Young-woo cross-examines Park's doctor. He agrees that subdural bleeding can come from injury or from illness. He also admits that Park had no skull fracture and no wound or bruise on his head, only minor injuries to the arms he raised. He says he diagnosed Park based on what he was told. When she suggests he should have checked, since the defendant could go to prison, the prosecution's objection is sustained.
Young-woo then establishes that Park was 81, had dementia and had a severe headache before the blow, a detail the doctor did not know. The doctor agrees that spontaneous hematomas are common in elderly dementia patients and concedes that one was possible here. The defense submits a diagnosis from three medical specialists naming a spontaneous subdural hematoma as Park's illness and cause of death. Young-woo argues there is no causal link between the blow and the death and asks the court to try Yeong-ran only for inflicting bodily injury.
Asked whether he will apply to change the indictment, the prosecutor says yes. The ruling comes back: Yeong-ran is not guilty of murder and receives probation for inflicting bodily injury. Yeong-ran comes to see Young-woo and thanks her.
At Gwang-ho's gimbap shop, a visitor arrives after closing time and greets Gwang-ho by name, saying it has been a while.
Up next: Extraordinary Attorney Woo Episode 2 recap. See every episode in the Extraordinary Attorney Woo episode guide.
